For many American entrepreneurs relocating to Portugal, forming or keeping a US LLC appears to offer flexibility and tax efficiency. However, while the structure can be efficient in certain fact patterns, its perceived advantages rest on administrative rulings that apply only to the taxpayers who requested them.
A US LLC in Portugal is therefore not a universal solution. Under a conservative and compliant approach, taxpayers should consider alternative corporate forms, such as C-Corporations or Portuguese companies, rather than relying on isolated precedents that may not hold in future interpretations.
How the current interpretation emerged
The Portuguese Tax Authority (Autoridade Tributária e Aduaneira) has issued two key binding rulings on US LLCs: Processo 2360/2016 and Ruling 26925/2024. Both examined the tax classification of income attributed to Portuguese residents who hold participations in US-based LLCs.In both cases, the authorities concluded that a US LLC is treated as an opaque entity under Portuguese law. Consequently, income distributed to the member was classified as “other income” from a foreign source, not as dividends, and, if the taxpayer qualified for Portugal’s special expatriate regime (NHR), it could be exempt from Portuguese taxation.
These rulings brought comfort to many expats reporting LLC income in Portugal, especially those with NHR status. However, it is crucial to understand the legal nature and limits of these decisions.
Why tax rulings are not general law
Under Article 68 of the Lei Geral Tributária (LGT), a binding ruling (“informação vinculativa”) is binding only on the tax authority and the specific taxpayer who requested it. It does not establish a general rule or binding precedent for other taxpayers.
This means that even though the 2016 and 2024 rulings were favourable, their conclusions cannot be automatically extended to everyone with a similar structure. Any other taxpayer applying the same interpretation assumes the risk entirely on their own.
Furthermore, the Portuguese Tax Authority may issue new rulings or internal circulars at any time, potentially adopting a stricter position or aligning its view with the Portuguese Tax Transparency Regime (Regime de Transparência Fiscal) applicable to certain partnerships and professional entities.
The risk of relying on administrative interpretation
While many advisers still promote the US LLC as a compliant vehicle under the NHR or IFICI regime, that position depends on administrative leniency, not statutory certainty. Future guidance could easily modify that interpretation in several ways:
- Re-characterisation as a transparent entity: If Portuguese authorities decide that a US LLC’s features resemble those of a Portuguese partnership (“sociedade de profissionais”), they could treat it as transparent, taxing members on the profits as they arise.
- Effective management in Portugal: If the LLC’s strategic or operational decisions are made from Portugal, the company could be deemed to have its place of effective management there, becoming a Portuguese tax resident.
- Reassessment under anti-avoidance principles: The Tax Authority may challenge structures that appear to shift income abroad while the economic activity is performed locally.
These risks are not theoretical. In practice, changes in interpretation often arise when the administration updates its internal criteria or responds to OECD recommendations. For this reason, prudent taxpayers avoid relying on unpublished or case-specific rulings to plan long-term investments.
Substance and management location matter
Even if an LLC is currently treated as opaque, that treatment depends on maintaining foreign management and genuine business substance outside Portugal. Any indication that the company is effectively managed from Portuguese territory, such as decision-making by a resident director, use of local offices, or client contracts negotiated from Portugal, may shift the source of income to Portugal.
Once reclassified as Portuguese-sourced income, the taxpayer could face full taxation under the Portuguese personal income tax (IRS) at progressive rates of up to 48 %, along with penalties and interest.
In short, the formal structure of an LLC is not sufficient protection. Substance and management must align with the narrative of a truly foreign entity.
Why C-Corporations offer greater certainty
From a prudential and compliance-driven perspective, C-Corporations (or other standard corporate vehicles) provide more predictable tax treatment under Portuguese and international rules.
A C-Corporation is clearly an opaque entity in both jurisdictions. Distributions are classified as dividends, and Portugal’s domestic rules and tax treaties provide established mechanisms for avoiding double taxation. The compliance burden may be higher, but the risk of future reclassification is significantly lower.
For individuals relocating to Portugal, holding business interests through a C-Corporation rather than an LLC avoids the uncertainty of how Portuguese authorities might interpret the income in future years. This approach aligns with the conservative principle of legal certainty over temporary efficiency.
Key takeaways for cautious taxpayers
The 2016 and 2024 rulings confirm favourable treatment only for those specific taxpayers.Portuguese law does not guarantee that the same approach will apply to other individuals.
Any future administrative change could alter how LLC income is classified and taxed.Maintaining management outside Portugal is essential, but it does not eliminate interpretive risk.
C-Corporations or local Portuguese companies offer greater legal clarity for long-term planning.
A prudent approach for new residents
Relocating to Portugal offers substantial lifestyle and fiscal advantages, but international structures must be evaluated under Portuguese domestic law, not foreign assumptions. A US LLC may appear convenient, yet it remains a grey area governed by administrative discretion.
Adopting a compliant and transparent structure from the outset reduces future disputes and ensures peace of mind. Professional guidance from experienced cross-border tax advisors is essential before relying on interpretations that are neither general nor permanent.
At Madeira Corporate Services, our team assists clients in evaluating foreign company structures, assessing Portuguese tax implications, and identifying compliant alternatives tailored to each client’s circumstances.
Contact us today for clear, independent advice on how to structure your international income securely and sustainably in Portugal.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. Tax laws and administrative interpretations may change. The information herein reflects the current understanding of Portuguese tax practice as of the date of publication. Readers should obtain personalised professional advice before making any decisions based on this material.
The founding of Madeira Corporate Services dates back to 1996. MCS started as a corporate service provider in the Madeira International Business Center and rapidly became a leading management company… Read more
